How To Conduct A Reference Check When Hiring

How To Conduct A Reference Check When Hiring

Hiring the right candidate is not just about assessing the skills and experience they bring to the table but also about verifying their background and work ethics through a reference check. The critical role that thorough checking plays in the recruitment process can not be underrated. It is not just about filling a position but ensuring a long-term fit that will contribute positively to your organization’s goals and culture. This guide outlines how to conduct an effective reference check that can help you make informed hiring decisions.

The Importance of a Reference Check

A reference check allows employers to verify information provided by candidates regarding their work history and behavior in professional settings. It provides a chance to confirm the details listed on their resume and discussed during the interview, from job responsibilities to achievements. More importantly, it offers insights into the candidate’s interpersonal skills, reliability, and how they handle workplace challenges.

Conducting a check is crucial because it minimizes the risk of hiring errors which can be costly. A bad hire can lead to further recruitment costs, decreased team morale, and lost productivity. Therefore, understanding how to effectively carry out this step is key to protecting your business from potential setbacks. No matter you’re hiring an administrative assistant or cleaning staff, ensuring only the most qualified and vetted individuals are placed in roles that match their skills and your needs is important.

Preparing for the Reference Check

Before you pick up the phone to call a reference, it is essential to prepare. This preparation involves several steps to ensure that you gather meaningful information that can influence your hiring decision positively.

  • Obtain Consent from the Candidate

Firstly, always make sure to obtain the candidate’s consent to contact their references. This is not only a matter of courtesy but also compliance with privacy laws. Candidates should provide you with a list of references upon request.

This list should ideally include former managers, colleagues, and other relevant contacts who can provide valuable insights into the candidate’s professional life.

  • Develop a Structured Questionnaire

Having a structured set of questions is crucial to maintain consistency across all reference checks. This approach ensures that you gather comparable information for all candidates, aiding in fair and objective decision-making.

Your questions should cover a range of topics including the candidate’s responsibilities, performance, work ethic, and interpersonal skills. It is also beneficial to tailor some questions to suit the specific requirements of the role they are applying for.

  • Schedule a Suitable Time for the Reference Check

When you reach out to references, be considerate of their time. Schedule a call that is convenient for them, and ensure you are clear about how long the call will take. This respect for their time will facilitate a more open and cooperative discussion.

  • Set Clear Objectives for Each Call

Each check should have clear objectives. Decide what specific information you need to verify or clarify about the candidate. This focus will help you steer the conversation effectively and ensure that you cover all critical aspects.

Conducting the Reference Check

With preparations in place, you can proceed to the actual reference checking. Here is how to conduct the check effectively.

How To Conduct A Reference Check When Hiring

  • Verify Basic Information

Begin each call by verifying the basic information about the candidate. Confirm their job title, the period they worked with the reference, and their key responsibilities. This step helps to ensure that the information the candidate provided matches the reference’s records.

  • Discuss the Candidate’s Performance and Competencies

Shift the conversation to discuss the candidate’s skills and performance. Ask the reference to evaluate the candidate’s specific skills and how they managed their daily tasks. For instance, understanding how the candidate handled deadlines, project management, and teamwork can give you a better insight into their suitability for the job.

  • Inquire About Interpersonal Skills

Interpersonal skills are crucial for most jobs. Discuss with the reference how the candidate interacts with others in the workplace. This includes their ability to communicate effectively, resolve conflicts, and collaborate with teams.

For roles that require high emotional intelligence, such as positions involving grief and loss counseling, understanding the candidate’s empathy and interpersonal skills is particularly critical.

  • Ask About Areas for Improvement

No candidate is perfect, and understanding their areas for improvement can help you determine if they are a fit for your organization and where they might need support. Ask the reference to specify areas where the candidate could improve. This inquiry not only helps you understand the candidate’s weaknesses but also their willingness to accept feedback and desire to improve.

  • Discuss the Candidate’s Reliability and Ethics

Reliability and ethical behavior are pillars of a good employee. It is vital to ask the reference about the candidate’s punctuality, ability to meet deadlines, and adherence to company policies and ethics. You might ask questions like, “Can you provide an example of a situation where the candidate demonstrated exceptional adherence to workplace ethics?” This type of inquiry helps you understand the candidate’s moral compass and reliability in a professional setting.

  • Understand the Candidate’s Reason for Leaving

Knowing why the candidate left their previous job is crucial as it can indicate patterns that might be relevant to your decision. Ask the reference about the circumstances surrounding the candidate’s departure. Was it a voluntary resignation? Was it a mutual decision? Understanding the context of their previous job exits can provide insight into their career goals and stability.

  • Gauge the Reference’s Overall Enthusiasm

The tone and enthusiasm of the reference when discussing the candidate can be very telling. Listen not only to what they say but how they say it. Enthusiastic, unsolicited praise can be a strong endorsement, whereas hesitation or vague responses might indicate concerns. Pay attention to the overall sentiment expressed by the reference to gauge their genuine perception of the candidate.

  • Ask for Additional References

Sometimes, one reference check might not be enough to get a full picture of the candidate. If you feel it necessary, ask the reference if they can recommend others who might also provide valuable insights. Additional references can either corroborate what you have already heard or provide new perspectives on the candidate.

Once you have gathered all the necessary information, it is important to analyze the data thoughtfully. Compare notes from different references to look for consistencies or discrepancies. This analysis will help you build a more complete picture of the candidate’s capabilities and fit within your organization.

Never underestimate the power of a well-conducted check. It is a crucial step that can prevent potential hiring mistakes and contribute to better team dynamics and productivity. At General Workforce, we consider this process an essential part of our recruitment strategy to ensure we bring on board only the most suitable candidates who align with our values and work culture.

Implementing a structured and thorough reference check process as described can significantly enhance your hiring practices, ensuring you invest in the right people who will contribute to your organization’s success.


Scroll to Top
Live representative +1-718-674-6829